A hotel brand sells one thing above everything else: the promise that the hotel you book will be like the last one. This paper asks whether that promise survives the arrival of a dog, in the two luxury portfolios we have assessed most completely, and finds that it does not. InterContinental runs from the best dog hotel in our entire dataset, an A+ in Miami, to a hotel in San Diego that scores below zero. Fairmont, a brand that markets its dog friendly heritage, runs from an A+ in Los Angeles to a cluster of Fs across three continents, with exactly half of its 62 assessed hotels meeting the six minimum requirements and a further 19 refusing dogs altogether.
None of it is a brand policy. In both portfolios the dog fee runs from free to $250 with no relationship to what the dog gets, the weight limit runs from none to a figure that excludes most family dogs, and the brand name tells a dog owner nothing about what they will get. Kimpton, under the same roof as InterContinental, is the counterpoint: one brand level dog policy produces no F grades across 25 hotels, and Hilton has written a dog bed and bowls into the brand standard of more than 4,600 hotels. The paper names every hotel in three full leaderboards, explains why the variance exists, and sets out the six rules a brand would need to adopt for its name to mean the same thing to a dog owner at every property.